Older Posts

Rookie of the Year Ballot

The Seamheads Postseason Award Ballots that we shared last month didn't ask for Rookie of the Year votes. Here is our unsolicited Rookie of the Year ballot for the ol' blog.

American League Rookie of the Year
1.) Elvis Andrus
If he could learn to hit a bit, he could be the AL's version of what Jose Reyes was supposed to be.

Rookie of the Year Ballot2.) Rick Porcello
Loyal readers of this space know how much we appreciate Porcello. He had an incredible season, as a 20-year old who flourished a rotation spot for a team that was competitive through 163 games. He didn't strike out a lot of guys, but I think some on the job training in his early 20's could teach him a thing, or two, about strikeout pitches.

3.) Gordon Beckham
Bechham was a big part of the White Sox getting on track this season. With Kenny Williams trading for Mark Teahen, Beckham will be moving back to second base next season, upping his fantasy value along the way.

Mention: Jeff Niemann, Brett Anderson, Nolan Reimold, Andrew Bailey

National League Rookie of the Year
1.) Chris Coghlan
Coghlan was under the radar, with a .368 OBP in June, slowed down a bit in July... and then, he just got scorching hot. His Batting Averages in August, September, & October were: .385, .382, .462. (Also look for Coghlan to move to move to 2nd base next year, if/when the Marlins trade Dan Uggla.)

Rookie of the Year Ballot2.) Tommy Hanson
Some numbers: 11 Wins in 21 starts, 2.89 ERA, 522 batters faced, 105 Hits, 46 walks.

3.) Andrew McCutchen
Anyone who has seen this guy play immediately saw the talent, quick swing, tremendous speed, and exciting style. Yes, I just went from numbers for Hanson and hyperbole for McCutchen. Most of McCutchen's numbers don't jump out, but here are a couple of doozies... McCutchen made the league minimum salary ($400,000). He was a midseason call-up, so he only played 108 games. His performance for the Pirates was valued at 15.8 million dollars, in 108 games.

Mention: Dexter Fowler, JA Happ, Casey McGehee, Randy Wells

Varitek Valued?

Varitek Valued?In the expected news of the day department, the Red Sox will not pick up Jason Varitek's option. Jason Varitiek has five days to exercise his $3 million option (plus $2mm incentives) to return to the Red Sox as co-catcher with Victor Martinez.

In about half a day, he will likely decide to return to his position of Captain of the Red Sox. Is Boras still his agent? Wouldn't this be an exciting time for his agent to pull off some nearly-tampered deal to get his client a well-payed, two-year deal?


Varitek Valued?It would be fun to see Red Sox fans freak out and bash their long-time leader if he bolted for Torre & Mattingley's Dodgers to be co-catcher with Russell Martin. The heart and soul of so many Red Sox squads could join forces with Yankee legends on the blue pinstripes of the West Coast.

It doesn't matter. I don't think Varitek has that much to offer while standing in the batter's box. I just wanted to throw out my own hot stove rumor, in the spirit of terribly far-fetched rumors that have no basis in fact.

In an unexpected bit of reporting, an anonymous source added, "no comment."

Prospect Spotlight: Tommy Manzella

This is the first in our long anticipated Prospect Spotlight series. If you enjoy this post, please email mosquito @ keeping me up half the night [dot] com.

"How about a shout out for Tommy Manzella of Tulane fame. Finally made it to the show and got a hit in his first at bat. Rumor has it that he might be Adam Everett 2.0" -- Brillian Reader Osh - Sept 17, 2009

"GM Ed Wade when asked about Tejada: “At this point, we’re prepared to commit to Tommy Manzella playing shortstop." Tejada could return at 3B" -- the Twittering thumbs of Brian McTaggart - Nov 6, 2009

More Wade, via McTaggart: "Tommy is ready to play in the big leagues, and we think Miggy is capable of playing third base. That's been discussed last year, and we didn't feel it was right to make the move at that point in time. [Geoff] Blum was playing well at third and did a good job and Miggy was doing well at shortstop. It didn't make sense to walk down that path last year." - Nov 6, 2009

The Early Story
According to the Tulane Official Athletic Site, Thomas Samuel Manzella, Jr. was born in New Orleans and sports a hometown of Chalmette, Louisiana. While Tommy was conceivably growing up in Chalmette, the town hosted what I can say with experience was one of the most unique and colorful Mardi Gras parades, Shangri-LA. The Mystic Krewe of Shangri-LA become such a hit in the late 1990's that they were invited to move the parade to New Orleans. With the tough economic times, they had to scale back this year to an "Imperial Stroll" through the French Quarter. If any of our readers have the crazy idea of attending another Mardi Gras, see if Shangri-LA coincides with your trip. The true spirit of Mardi Gras should be firmly embraced by this krewe.


Prospect Spotlight: Tommy ManzellaWhere were we? Oh yeah, well Manzella was a terrific student and he hit .360 with 3 HR's in his Senior Year. That is showing no power.


His Freshman season at Tulane produced an empty .296 batting average. He only managed 8 walks in 192 plate appearances, again flashing no power with only 6 doubles, 3 triples, & 3 HR's. Tommy did not steal bases particularly well, with 4 steals in 7 attempts.



The next three seasons at Tulane were more impressive. For three straight seasons, from 2003 - '05, NCAA pitchers could not seem to cool him down. His worst batting average those seasons was .311, and he muscled up to hit 80 extra base hits. He never raised his proclivity to walk to an acceptable level, as his college career high of 20 walks came his Senior year in over 310 plate appearances.


Prospect Spotlight: Tommy ManzellaMinor Leagues
I want Tommy to be a good major leaguer, but minor league slash numbers of .268/.321/.374 do not lead to great hitting success in the major leagues. Other than showing more doubles power and having sporadic success on the basepaths, Manzella's numbers never suggested adjustments in his hitting approach for improved plate discipline. He even showed less ability to avoid strikeouts as a professional, with a couple of alarming campaigns with 80 and 99 strikeouts.

Next Steps
Indications scream that Manzella will be given a chance at the everyday job for Brad Mills' 2010 Houston Astros. Defensive metrics aren't so available at the minor league level, but you'd think that a guy who can't hit minor league pitching with authority would be a great defensive player. When considering that Manzella is an old rookie, at 27 years old in 2010, a projection of Adam Everett 2.0 may be considered Tommy Manzella's best-case scenario.

Canyon of Heroes

Loyal readers, it has been an honour touring the wonderful game of baseball since this season's Opening Day. Our highly anticipated hot stove league coverage should begin soon. (teaser: tommy m.)

Here is an extensive photo library of the Yankees Championship Parade from deep within the archaic bowels of the Canyon of Heroes.
***
Canyon of Heroes
Canyon of Heroes
Canyon of Heroes
Canyon of Heroes
The construction workers had the best views on top of the scaffold.
Canyon of HeroesSorry if some of these pictures are fuzzy, tasteless, or worthless. I think the float in the fuzzy picture above had the trophy.

Canyon of Heroes
Canyon of Heroes
Canyon of HeroesMVP Hideki Matsui was the first player to appear in the parade. The crowd chanted MVP! MVP!
Canyon of Heroes

Canyon of HeroesMost people didn't realize Brett Gardner was on this float. I think Xavier Nady and a few other players were there, too.
Canyon of Heroes
Canyon of Heroes
Canyon of Heroes
Canyon of Heroes
This fan was a riot, straight out of "A Bronx Tale". My favorite was when he was screaming and pointing at a float yelling, "Giuliani! Giuliani! Giuliani!!"
Canyon of Heroes The crowds were squeezing into Broadway, and the buzz in the air was getting louder. Why?

Canyon of HeroesIt's Gangster AlexRod! Fans near me were yelling, "Arod's got his own float!" I can't help but have Kobe Bryant flashbacks to the times I lived in LA and he was celebrating his first Lakers' championship without any teammates.

Canyon of Heroes
Canyon of Heroes
Where's Kate? Is that AlexRod's ex wife? I could see her making her presence a requirement if her kids were to be on the AlexFloat.
Canyon of Heroes
Canyon of Heroes
Canyon of HeroesSeeing AJ Burnett on his own float made me think that maybe Boras clients negotiate that into their deals. Why wouldn't the Yankees agree to giving them their own float if they win the title? They just want to win the title.

Canyon of Heroes I was the only one around us who recognized Burnett. Not a good thing.
Canyon of Heroes
Canyon of HeroesJerry Hairston, Jr keeps the ex-Cub vibes around.

Canyon of HeroesThis was a fun float with Sabathia and Teixeira. The Bronx Tail fan and I were both yelling "CC! CC! CC!" like schoolchildren. Sabathia is a star.

Canyon of Heroes
Canyon of Heroes Terrible shot, but that is the top of Robinson Cano's head.

Canyon of HeroesFans going crazy...
Canyon of Heroes
They're squeezing in... could that be him?
Canyon of Heroes Oh yeah, Cap'n Jetes!
Canyon of Heroes Hang loose, my man.
Canyon of Heroes Posada and Jeter were on the same float. That was nice.

Canyon of Heroes

Canyon of Heroes
Pettitte looked like a man who would only do HGH for the benefit of his teammates.

Canyon of Heroes
Canyon of Heroes
Moving down towards Bowling Green...

Canyon of Heroes
Canyon of Heroes

And the best game finishing pitcher of all time brought the parade to a close. With all respect for Matsui, Rivera is our pick for 2009 World Series MVP. As Harry would say, "They're DANCING in the streets of Panama City."

BAseball Reality Tour - Animal Style

First, let's get this awkwardness out of the way... The ol' blog has been silent for, gasp, more than a month. I am sorry to the gaggles of brilliant readers who've been waiting and waiting and waiting. Still, my purpose right now is to sadly announce that we shouldn't expect posts multiple times a week anymore.

I'm announcing it now, so that I don't have to apologize every time more than a week passes between posts. The reasons our posts will be less frequent are simple: I'm too busy with work to spend the time it takes to make the posts somewhat worthwhile. Perhaps we shouldn't be sad. Maybe it's a good thing. I'm hoping that the quality of posts will increase, while the quantity decreases.

In an ideal world, the BAseball Reality Tour will be the Interweb's version of In-N-Out Burger. For those of you that aren't privy to being around In-N-Out, it is quite possibly the best fast food chain of all time. The food is fresh and delicious, and the employees are clean, bright, and helpful. That's not where the analogy makes a smidgen of sense. One of the strategies that makes In-N-Out so special is that they aren't everywhere. Even though the demand is high, In-N-Out has a strategy that their restaurants should be a special occasion. They may take more than five or ten minutes to get to, unlike the local McDonald's that is withing a ten minute drive of 98% of homes in America. Could it be that the extra time in getting there makes the food taste better?

Thank goodness that ugliness is behind us. You'll never have to read me apologize again for delays between posts. Phew. Without further ado, here is our most recent literary double-double with no onions...

About a week and a half ago, I submitted my "ballot" for MLB yearly awards to a Seamheads group I'm a member of on Facebook. It's a nice group for hard core baseball fans because they occasionally bring up topics of interest within the contexts of current events, history, and Hall of Fame debates. For those of you interested in joining,
here is the link.

The administrator of the Seamheads group, emigo Mike Lynch, asked us to submit a ballot for MVP and Cy Young in each league. Just like the BBWAA writers' ballots, we were to include five choices for MVP's and three for Cy Young. Since award voting always leads to valuable discussion, I thought I'd share my ballot here to get the ol' blog back on track. Keep in mind, these are awards for performance in the regular season, so any postseason accomplishments or failures should be ignored.

NL MVPBAseball Reality Tour - Animal Style
1. Albert Pujols, Cardinals
2. Hanley Ramirez, Marlins
3. Matt Kemp, Dodgers
4. Tim Lincecum, Giants
5. Prince Fielder, Brewers

NL Cy Young
1. Tim Lincecum, Giants
2. Adam Wainwright, Cardinals
3. Josh Johnson, Marlins

AL MVPBAseball Reality Tour - Animal Style
1. Joe Mauer, Twins
2. Derek Jeter, Yankees
3. Zack Greinke, Royals
4. Kevin Youkilis, Red Sox
5. Ben Zobrist, Rays

AL Cy Young
1. Zack Greinke, Royals
2. Justin Verlander, Twins
3. Felix Hernandez, Mariners

I think balloting is open through the rest of the world Series, so if you'd like to participate, join the group on this link, and post your ballot on the group wall.

Rockies Imploding?

Rockies Imploding?It's a long night over here, working with computer programmers on the other side of the globe.

I just tuned in to the Giants v Rockies game to watch Franklin Morales turn into Andy Pratt.

The Rockies are having a dreadful 9th inning, and the last playoff spot may be up for grabs at this moment.

If anyone is awake right now, tune in to ESPN. (You may want to have the game on MUTE.)


Update: Rafael Betancourt came in and took care of business for the Rocks. He first induced a tailor made 6-4-3 double play ball, but Clint Barmes decided not to catch the throw from Troy Tulowitzki... for a Troy Tulowitzki error... Hmmm. This made the score 4-2 Rockies, and after the pinch runner, blog favorite Eugenio Velez, stole second base, the tying runs were in scoring position. Betancourt settled down by getting Edgar Renteria to pop out, Randy Winn hit a meaningless RBI groundout, and Nate Schierholtz struck out swinging.

Where Have We Been?

So, here we sit on Saturday, September 5th, and we didn't do a Sept 1st update to our season predictions. How embarrassing. If it weren't for the cries of a few loyal readers, we'd just be moving right along with posts selected from events such as...

- Felix Pie being the worst hitter in a long time to hit for the cycle.
- Cycles becoming more common than no-hitters.
- My growing hatred for loving the Cubs.
- Prospect spotlights on recent call ups Buster Posey, Cameron Maybin, and Michael Brantley.
- My shock & appreciation for what Neftali Feliz is doing.

We may be able to address some or all of these ideas in future posts. For now, let's take a look at our updated power rankings, season awards, and postseason outlook.

Power Rankings
30.) Kansas City Royals
- Joe sums up the '09 Royals pretty marvelously here.

29.) Washington Nationals
- The Nationals climbed out of last place in our rankings by taking two of three at Wrigley Field last week. The Cubs should probably be down around here, too, considering the Nats followed their Chicago trip by losing seven in a row.

28.) Pittsburgh Pirates
- Much like the Royals, the Pirates have a process. Some of their recent moves have been peculiar, but they haven't been the outright punchlines that the Royals have been delivering.

27.) New York Mets
- Segueing towards another team that has had punchline after punchline, the Mets have been an embarrassment to their fans, employees, and all of our past season projections where we thought they would figure it out and make the playoffs.

26.) Oakland A's
- There's not much to say about the A's this year. They banked a little too much on young pitchers and aging hitters. Neither group established themselves, but we can see some glory days ahead for guys like Brett Anderson, Trevor Cahill, and Andrew Bailey.

25.) Cleveland Indians
- With AL Central parity being what it is, the Indians can have a miserable year like they did this season and still compete with a one or two year turnaround plan. They have some young pieces on both sides of the ball, and with better luck we expect them to compete next summer.

24.) Cincinnati RedsWhere Have We Been?
- Dusty Baker's managerial career has been a clashing example of "strikes & gutters". In his first season as a manager, his Giants went 103-59. From 1997 through 2004, his Giants and Cubs teams averaged 90.5 wins. Since then, he's become a 70-win manager who continuously says things that make him the laughing stock of sabermetric circles. It'll be tough for him, or anyone else to top his "clogging up the bases isn't that great to me" line.


23.) San Diego Padres
- The Pads didn't compete this year, so it's almost sad that we consider seven teams to be in worse shape than them. They do still have an entering-his-prime Adrian Gonzalez, Heath Bell, and some young pieces like Kyle Blanks, Everth Cabrera, and Mat Latos. A big plus was finding a team to take Jake Peavy's damaged goods off their hands, in exchange for some actually good young players.

22.) Arizona Diamondbacks
- Let's say the D'backs are the NL's version of the Cleveland Indians. They have some pieces, suffered pretty debilitating injuries, and are in a relatively winnable division.

21.) Baltimore Orioles
- At the sake of sounding redundant, we've made it clear that we love the young Orioles. If they were in any other division, we'd expect them to compete in 2010. Valuable young pieces that any team would want include: Nick Markakis, Adam Jones, Matt Wieters, Chris Tillman, Brian Matusz, and Jake Arrieta. Since, they're in the AL East, they would need about six or seven guys to have a career year. That's more likely to happen in 2011 or '12.

20.) Houston AstrosWhere Have We Been?
- The Astros competed a bit longer than anyone not named Drayton McLain expected. They have an undesirable mix of expensive and aging players. They need to find more inexpensive, young, and talented players to lead them in the next decade. Hopefully, guys like Oswalt, Berkman, and maybe even Carlos Lee can still contribute when the Astros are relevant again. Heck, it could/should be next season. It'll be an action packed offseason for the Astros. They'll probably get a new manager and should look to trade Lee.

19.) Chicago Cubs
- A couple of months ago, when we did our first power rankings, brilliant reader Osh chimed in to castigate us for having the Cubs ranked so much ahead of the Astros. It turns out he was right, but not because the Astros were any better than we thought. Sadly, it's because the Cubs are awful. I like Jim Hendry, but I cannot understand the moves to bring in Milton Bradley, Kevin Gregg, and Aaron Miles, while letting Kerry Wood, Mark DeRosa, and Henry Blanco walk.

18.) Toronto Blue Jays
- The Blue Jays suffer from the same affliction as the Orioles and Rays, but they have a solid base with which to compete. They have an abundance of young starting pitchers, a young stud in Adam Lind, and the payroll potential to have a solid team every season.

17.) Milwaukee Brewers
- Rob Neyer had a recent post wondering why the Brewers are drawing so well at the gate, when they aren't actually contenders. In our honest opinions, they are a young team, with some good infield bats, and a #1 starter in Yovani Gallardo. We're in the camp that they should trade Prince Fielder for a package of young players that will make them competitive for the next four of five seasons. Look for J.J. Hardy to get moved this offseason, as well.

16.) Chicago White Sox
- I don't like to make fun of Kenny Williams. I like Kenny Williams, and I love his moxie. He will make the move he wants to make, without worrying about what others think. I don't think Jake Peavy or Alex Rios were wise investments, but the White Sox weren't going to win with what they had. It'll be interesting to see what they do with Jermaine Dye this winter, and if they choose to capitalize on whatever value they can get for Bobby Jenks.

15.) Minnesota Twins
- Every day, it seems like the Twins are either falling out of the race or getting back into it. That should be a theme to their clubs for the next few seasons. In the long term, there are two stories... how's the new stadium going to be? And, can they keep Joe Mauer?

14.) Atlanta Braves
- Bobby Cox continues to make his case for Cooperstown by having teams that are always competitive. Braves fans should be thrilled to see the progression of Tommy Hanson. He has been the most promising looking rookie pitcher this season.

13.) Seattle Mariners
- The Mariners have followed the Rays revolution to capitalize on the undervalued ability to play good defense. This should be the next Moneyball-esque arbitrage the league sees throughout the next couple of years. When Billy Beane was building competitive, underpaid teams during the Moneyball era, they capitalized on the fact that few teams valued On-Base Percentage enough. Of course, that has changed as now very few teams are being run with Dusty Baker's mindset of Batting Average and RBI's. So, up and coming teams need to look for the next undervalued talent. Two years ago, the Rays improved drastically by getting better defensively. This past year, we've seen teams like Seattle and Texas improve for the same reason. We think this offseason, we will see teams like Seattle, Texas, Tampa Bay, Oakland, Boston, and the Yankees. drive up the price of elite defenders in a way we haven't seen before.

12.) Florida Marlins Where Have We Been?
- The Marlins are still in it and have proven once again that there is a lot to be said for having three to four year cycle plans, if you're a low budget team. Their process is to build a great team, win the World Series, trade everyone for more prospects and compete again in four years. At least they can give their fans something to root for every few years. Is it better to struggle as an 80-win team every year, than to go from 60 wins to 90 wins every few years? I don't think so.

11.) San Francisco Giants
- At the beginning of the year, we expected to Giants to lose a lot of low scoring games. On the contrary, they've been right there all season. Tim Lincecum and Matt Cain give them the 1-2 punch that can take a team to a World Series. If they squeak into the playoffs, I wouldn't be surprised to see them go all the way.

10.) Colorado Rockies
- The Rockies stand in the Giants' way, as Wild Card contenders. I think this race will go to the last week of the year, but I have the Rockies here because they seem a little more balanced. While the Giants have the better pitching, I think Ubaldo, Troy, and the rest of the guys are going to pull it off.
9.) Tampa Bay Rays
- Is it possible that Rays fans were spoiled last year? They should be ecstatic with the way this season's team has competed, but alas coming in 3rd place isn't fun for anybody.

8.) Texas Rangers
- Maybe the most surprising team this season has been the Rangers. Again, they've improved their defense drastically by moving Michael Young to 3rd base and advancing Elvis Andrus a season before anyone expected. Their pitching has been steady and dynamic, and we see the future to be even brighter for Nolan's gang in the next decade. Keep an eye out for Justin Smoak, Derek Holland, and the aforementioned Neftali Felix to really shine next season.

7.) Detroit Tigers
- This season is starting to look a lot like 2006. And, that's a good thing for the Tigers.

6.) St. Louis CardinalsWhere Have We Been?
- The Cardinals have built an organization that plays games the right way, finds the best roles for their players, and rewards their fanbase with a competitive team year after year. It helps that the fans are so nice to new players that guys like Matt Holliday fall in love with the place and want to give them a hometown discount to return. Unless Scott Boras' commission is more important that Matt Holliday's success, he should resign with St. Louis and continue to reap the rewards of batting adjacent to Mr. Albert Pujols.

5.) Philadelphia Phillies
- The defending champs are in the process of fine tuning themselves into playoff shape. Cole Hamels and Cliff Lee give them a 1-2 punch to survive, and the key will be the bats. Will J-Ro get hot and stay hot in October? They'll need him. And, is Chase Utley playing hurt? Will he be able to drag his bad hip around at such a high level as he did last Fall? They'll need him to do that again, and it looks like he could realy use an extended rest. A key to their season will be the impact that Brett Myers has on the bullpen. I think if he can show some level of success and the ability to pitch on consecutive days, they'll make him the closer.

4.) Los Angeles Dodgers
- Joe Torre has been on cruise control seemingly since April 15th. In spite of the disappearance of Rafael Furcal, this team is talented enough to make the playoffs with Joe Nedney managing them. Their keys to a title rest on the shoulders of Chad Billingsley and Clayton Kershaw.

3.) Los Angeles Angels
- Mike Scoscia's club is doing things differently. They play NL baseball in the AL. They have a lot of free swinging guys, who are changing their ways with help of Bobby Abreu's leadership. The success is unmistakable, and for this inexperienced blogger, their success is admittedly somewhat inexplicable.

2.) Boston Red Sox
- While everyone was jumping off the Red Sox bandwagon the last seven or eight weeks, I've been getting comfortable by laying down in my own row. This is a long season, and teams will struggle. The Yankees looked lost in April & May, and just because the Red Sox have lost some steam in the second half of the season doesn't mean they won't win "the tournament" in October.

1.) New York YankeesWhere Have We Been?
- The Red Sox and Yankees are the top two teams in our rankings because - of course their offenses, but more than that - we believe in the power of the nasty boys. Ever since Lou Piniella unleashed Norm Charlton, Rob Dibble, and Randy Myers on the world in 1990 we've been big believers in the power of shortening a game. If you have three shutdown relievers, then you can basically win a game if you have the lead through six innings. We've seen this formula work for the Reds, Yankees, Angels and others throughout the past couple of decades.

It's probable that the postseason will come down to who's hitting, and who gets the best starting pitching. That is common. But, here is a vote for the ALCS being decided by the battle between the bullpens of the Red Sox (Ramon Ramirez, Manny Delcarmen, Hideki Okajima, Daniel Bard, Billy Wagner, and Jonathan Papelbon) and the Yankees (Hughes, Joba?, Rivera).

Postseason & Awards
As usual, please refer to our preseason predictions for our "on the record" picks. These monthly columns are a way of experimenting with what we see and what we feel each month as the season goes on.

NLDS
Cardinals over Rockies
Dodgers over Phillies

NLCS
Cardinals over Dodgers

NL MVP: Albert Pujols, St. Louis
NL Cy Young: Tim Lincecum, San Francisco
NL Rookie: Tommy Hanson, Atlanta
NL Manager: Tony LaRussa, St. Louis*

* Imagine is somehow Pujols, Wainright (or Carpenter), Rasmus, and LaRussa swept all four of these awards for St. Louis. These are the kinds of possibilities that make Cubs fans like me sick.

ALDS
Red Sox over Angels
Yankees over Tigers

ALCS
Red Sox over Yankees

AL MVP: Joe Mauer, Minnesota
AL Cy Young: Zack Greinke, Kansas City
AL Rookie: Elvis Andrus, Texas
AL Manager: Ron Washington, Texas

2009 World Series
Red Sox over Cardinals (again)

Position Players of the Future

Well, that was fun... looking at the Top 25 pitchers who made their debut this season. Let's waste some time now, looking at the hitters. Please note, this is an exercise that should be fraught with flaws because we are doing no math, looking at very few numbers, and just picking guys that we think should be good. By the way, there were more than 25 inspiring pitchers who made their debut this year. As you will see in the following list, the hitters have been less impressive. I'd say that really only about three people on this list have accomplished much this season.

25.) Bobby Scales, 2b
The one, true non-prospect on this list is 31-year old Bobby Scales. He made an inspirational impact with the Cubs this May, and no-one will be able to take that experience away from him. Unfortunately, very few forces out there will give Scales another taste of the show.

24.) Trent Oeltjen, OF
Oeltjen is another late bloomer. The 26-year old flashed some power & speed soon after his debut, but his true talent is showing as he is in the truest sense of the word a replacement-level player.

23.) Ramiro Pena, SS
Position Players of the FutureHere comes some name dropping... Pena is very close to the spotlight as the understudy of Captain Jetes. He has shown the ability to field his position with ease. Unfortunately, he hits a lot like Rey Ordonez. I'd say Pena's upside is that of Adam Everett, but a more realistic career arc for him to follow would probably be that of Pokey Reese, Desi Relaford or at best Alex Cora.

22.) Landon Powell, C
I don't know anything about Landon Powell. In fact, when I saw his name on the list of players to debut this year, I thought maybe this was Boog Powell. Alas, this is not Boog Powell, who actually debut'd in 1961, played 17 seasons, and retired with 1,776 hits, 339 HR's, and 134 OPS+. I should probably know more about Boog Powell and Landon Powell, as well. His numbers aren't actually impressive, but he plays catcher. Still, he's 27 years old, meaning that his days of actually getting better are few and far between.

What am I doing? Yesterday, I only wrote about the Top 10. Why didn't anyone interrupt me?

21.) Trevor Crowe, OF
20.) Xavier Paul, OF
Position Players of the Future19.) Jordan Schafer, OF
18.) Drew Stubbs, OF
17.) Gerardo Parra, OF
16.) Julio Borbon, OF
15.) Everth Cabrera, SS
14.) John Mayberry, OF
13.) Jason Jaramillo, C
12.) Tommy Everidge, 1b
11.) Michael Saunders, OF/3b


10.) Nolan Reimold, LF
Reimold has had typical rookie year ups & downs, but he's been able to do something right. I haven't looked up the numbers, but he's probably putting together quality at bats and driving in runs with timely hitting, or he's brainwashed his manager, coaches, and teammates with a really good first impression.

9.) Elvis Andrus, SS
Ramiro Pena is a world class all-glove, no-hit shortstop. Andrus, on the other hand, is an all-glove, no-hit shortstop prospect with youth, speed, and most importantly opportunity on his side. He's shown enough bat control to avoid outs just enough to be productive, while playing outstanding defense up the middle.

8.) Chris Coghlan, OF/3b
Position Players of the FutureCoghlan hasn't used his 3b experience in the show, but his ability to get on base has made him the leadoff hitter of one of the most potent offenses in the league. He has fringe power and fringe speed, but a knack for taking walks, avoiding outs, and scoring runs. We think he has a chance to become one of those productive player, professional hitter type guys. I wonder what team he'll be on after the Marlins.

7.) Kyle Blanks, OF/1b
While Coghlan's skills are generally thought of as reliable, Blanks is a riskier prospect. I mean that in the most literal way. His body type (huge) has a higher risk of injury, but it also has a higher risk of reward. If a kid this big and strong can learn to become a professional hitter, he will hit homeruns out of any ballpark. That is paramount to a Padres prospect, like Blanks. It'd be interesting to see how good the Padres can be after they get a bunch of good players for Heath Bell and especially Adrian Gonzalez.

6.) Fernando Martinez, OF
Position Players of the FutureFernando Martinez looked completely overmatched during his stint with the Mets. Heck, his career OBP in the Minor Leagues isn't even impressive. In the Minors, he strikes out too much and doesn't steal bases well, at all. All that being said, he is only 20 years old. He's a young player for Double A, so his struggles in Triple A and the big leagues can be forgiven. F-Mart i6'1", 190 lbs, and in a few years I think he'll be at least as good as Adam Jones.

5.) Matt LaPorta, OF
Highly touted prospect, Matt LaPorta, became a household name in some households when the Indians traded C.C. Sabathia for a package built around LaPorta. Some of Matt's minor league numbers have been Herculean, like his .384 OBP and .557 SLG. His performance at the Major League level has left something to be desired, but this guy should develop into a pretty dependable middle of the order bat.

4.) Gordon Beckham, 3bPosition Players of the Future
Beckham was a floppy haired B.M.O.C. at the University of Georgia last year. Kenny Williams selected him with the 8th overall pick in the draft fourteen months ago, and today he stands as a vital part of the White Sox. Beckham had a great spring, didn't make the Opening Day roster, but made the most of his time with the big club since his debut on June 4th.

3.) Colby Rasmus, OF
Rasmus had a disappointing 2008, or else he would have debut'd last year around the time Jay Bruce became everyone's favorite Natural. It seems like just yesterday that the Prospect Smackdown showcased Jay Bruce vs. Colby Rasmus. Over here at BAseball Reality Tour, we do not like Colby Rasmus. He's too good. He's on the Cardinals. He's not even that good, yet, and the Cardinals are in first place. We really hate the Cardinals. They are so freaking consistent. With Dave Duncan at Pitching Coach, they could sign Dave Dravecky this offseason, and he's win a at least a dozen games next year.

2.) Andrew McCutcheon, CF
Last year at this time, I had a Google reminder set for "Andrew McCutcheon". I wanted to get an email every single time a new article with the words "Andrew McCutcheon" appeared. I was trying to patiently await his arrival, and I didn't want to miss out when he got called up because I thought he was the next power/speed superstar. Anyway, reading so much about him oddly made my interest wane. Here is another example of missing out on someone pretty special. He does a very good job of filling out the box score with hits, runs, steals, etc. He's had some unexpected power outbursts, and he's been a very valuable member of the Pirates. Seeing him run live is breathtaking, as well. He's not Usain Bolt, but he has as good of wheels as anyone in the game right now.

1.) Matt Wieters, CPosition Players of the Future
I don't know why I still have Wieters listed at #1 on any list. He has disappointed fantasy owners around the world. The Orioles are still happy because they aren't playing for wins this season, he's getting to learn lessons about defense, calling a game, handling this young staff, and learning the tendencies of opposing big league players. He still has the unmistakable tools of size, strength, balance, and coordination. I think I'm putting him here because I'm afraid of cringing when I look back in a few years and see that I had Matt Wieters ranked below Matt LaPorta. Seriously, though, looking at Wieters' numbers, he has been outperformed by #13 on this list, Jason Jaramillo.

Did we leave anyone important out of the list? Are there any injustices we must answer for?